Closing Time

Oh my God! I am torn between how awesome this episode was and my annoyance at all of the plotholes! First, I shall sing all my praises Like Stormageddon, who I think is possibly the coolest person in the entire universe I shall name my first born after him, boy or girl Craig was good, again, and I liked the Doctor getting his hat, as little sense as that made.. Stetsons are cool Can't wait for the Season finale, which I hope will kick some serious ass I saw dinosaurs, daleks, eyepatch woman, river as eyepatch woman and so much else! But no Amy, so.. Also, next week's is called The Wedding of River Song for some reason Maybe her and the Doctor get married underwater

Now all the plotholes! How did the Doctor manage to age 200 years in one season, when David Tennant didn't age ONE hundred in four seasons, it doesn't make sense to me! :/ Although once again, I swear in the Impossible Astronaut, they mentioned that the suit was the size of a child & River is definitely an adult. Also, I still refuse to believe he will die. But if River was an adult when she did it, she can definitely remember killing him, which would mean that she could easily have set it up, like told them it was the real doctor when it wasn't..

hi. it was awesome

i dont know how the dcotor aged that quick but the doctor lies.

Yeah im confused about the astronaut thing as well, maybe she forgot that she did it when she was a girl.

It was cool Really liked Craig and Alfie/Stormageddon. Cool name

And next week's Looks chaotic, really good. But yeah, I'm suspecting River will find some way to save him, leaving most of the world to think she really killed him. Maybe even done to stop there being another attempt.

And I've no idea about the aging! Unless he did lie.

I don't think he lied, cos he had done everything in that book, meaning that in between ditching the Ponds and stopping by and seeing Craig, he did everything left to do in his life

Yeah, she will save him I was thinking that if she was an adult when she did it, she can remember it, and she could have lied to Amy & Rory to fuck with them, and he could not have actually died.

Would she really be that mean? No, I'm sticking by my guess, that she's been lying to the entire world in order to protect future him. I hope so, anyway. And I've no idea about the aging!! Defo plothole, unfortunately.

And the title, now I notice, makes it pretty clear this is the one they marry in. Unless it's a red herring. Which is actually more likely. It's like how The Doctor's Daughter made us all think it'd be about some old daughter of his appearing from the past, but it was Jenny.

Yup And we've already had one called the Doctor's Wife Yeah, I'm hoping that's why she did it

Also, I'm gonna bet the Doctor saves Melody and takes her to Amy, who may actually y'know.. be a little happy about that

Oh yeah That one was one hell of a red herring

You mean maybe she'll smile or something? Or do something other than selfishly go launch her own perfume and become some sort of celebrity?

Mrs P Sylar wrote:I don't think he lied, cos he had done everything in that book, meaning that in between ditching the Ponds and stopping by and seeing Craig, he did everything left to do in his life

Yeah, she will save him I was thinking that if she was an adult when she did it, she can remember it, and she could have lied to Amy & Rory to fuck with them, and he could not have actually died.

i don't think he did everything in river songs book. Because river mentioned doing LOADS of things before the Doctor died and at the time that River got taken, she mentioned that she did many things with the doctor, which has not happened yet.

Wayward Daughter wrote: Would she really be that mean? No, I'm sticking by my guess, that she's been lying to the entire world in order to protect future him. I hope so, anyway. And I've no idea about the aging!! Defo plothole, unfortunately.

And the title, now I notice, makes it pretty clear this is the one they marry in. Unless it's a red herring. Which is actually more likely. It's like how The Doctor's Daughter made us all think it'd be about some old daughter of his appearing from the past, but it was Jenny.

an underwater wedding

Mrs P Sylar wrote:Yup And we've already had one called the Doctor's Wife Yeah, I'm hoping that's why she did it

Also, I'm gonna bet the Doctor saves Melody and takes her to Amy, who may actually y'know.. be a little happy about that

Wayward Daughter wrote:Oh yeah That one was one hell of a red herring

You mean maybe she'll smile or something? Or do something other than selfishly go launch her own perfume and become some sort of celebrity?

i have know idea why they made her a celeb :/

Did she? All I remember are the events she mentioned when she first appeared, which were the crash of the Byzantine, and Demon's Run. They've had both of them, now. I don't doubt there's more to come, though

And it is bizarre that an underwater wedding is now sounding awesome to me

They just did it to have her appear last week But it makes her look shallow and the world's worst mother, even more so than before, really. I really didn't like it.

Wayward Daughter wrote:Oh yeah That one was one hell of a red herring

You mean maybe she'll smile or something? Or do something other than selfishly go launch her own perfume and become some sort of celebrity?

I doubt she'll smile, Lowri, she just got her daughter, don't push it

Wayward Daughter wrote:Did she? All I remember are the events she mentioned when she first appeared, which were the crash of the Byzantine, and Demon's Run. They've had both of them, now. I don't doubt there's more to come, though

And it is bizarre that an underwater wedding is now sounding awesome to me

They just did it to have her appear last week But it makes her look shallow and the world's worst mother, even more so than before, really. I really didn't like it.

It's not bizarre, that's awesome

And me neither There's no point to making her famous, except possibly just to mention that she's 'the girl who's tired of waiting' or some shit

Is it meant to mean she's tired of waiting for him to rescue Melody?

Nah, I'm guessing it's a reference to the way Amy's always been called the Girl who waited, when really, all she did was wait 13 years or some shit. Rory waited 2000 years & she's still fucking him over.

If it's that, then it means she's given up on having him in her life, and having adventures with him etc. Which is shit, because they're gonna be in the Christmas special at least, its confirmed. They should only do something like that when someone's stopping for good.

I know Maybe it'll be important in the Christmas special? I know that Karen Gillian isn't going to do a new season though.

I've heard a summary of the Christmas one, but by now I've forgotten it Think it's another one based on some classic story, though.

cool

Weren't you the one complaining last year that it had too much story and not enough action?

Think he was I heard it was WW2 themed again or something?

you can still have action in a classic story

Course you can

Mrs P Sylar wrote:Think he was I heard it was WW2 themed again or something?

Possibly. That kinda sounds familiar.

Superheroesfanatic-IR wrote:you can still have action in a classic story

Have you heard or read any of them?

only a few :/

I mean a classic one packed ful of action is santa claus. I mean whats not to love. And the action in that is... ermmm...... very non- limitied

Santa Claus isn't a classic!! It's not even a book, it's a myth

BLASPHEMY

I really hate to prove you both wrong, but Santa isn't a myth or a book. It's just some guy tryna live his life.