Season 7 Episode 4: Defending Your Life

What did you think?

Personally think it was ok Spend a lot of it wondering why Dean and not Sam/both of them, but I guess it was the whole Hell/jumping in thing. Also wonder why John wasn't called as witness (apart from being unable to get the actor ) since then all Osiris would have to do was ask why he'd died.

I was questioning their choice in witnesses, as well, if I'm honest The thing he feels most guilty about is Jo, not his parents or any of the other countless people I did begin to ship Dean/Jo right at the end though, so some reason, I thought it was really sweet

Sam was a fantastic lawyer, and I actually really enjoyed, thought it was a good episode I prefer the idea that Dean was wrong, and the third witness was John & not Amy Pond, though

I actually never questioned why Sam wasn't on trial, I'm not sure why.. I just knew that if either brother would be on trial for guilt, it'd be Dean, cos he's the older brother, he blames himself for everything, cos it's his job to look after Sammy

Yeah, he is the one who seems to grab any weight he can and almost eagerly puts it on his own shoulders Season 5 made that really obvious.

That's actually a good theory Except maybe the idea was not to prove the guilt, but to make Sam loose trust in him? Amy'd do that.

I'm trying to work out why it was Jo. All I can think of really is her age I think she's easily the youngest of the allies they've lost. And maybe he felt more guilty because of her obvious crush on him

It was really sweet It more made me pity her ghost than ship them, though, cause I was seeing it as possibly platonic/siblingly as well as possibly romantic?

I could never truly like Dean/Jo, I just thought the ending was really sweet And I liked how happy she was to accept it was daddy issues instead of just having a crush on Dean, I preferred that idea

Yeah, it's quite obvious Dean blames himself for everything - he was doing it back in Season 2 when John died, although that was technically his fault I thought John'd be the second witness (I read that Jo was returning so guessed she'd be number 1) but then when Sam got called up, I assumed John'd be last, but then they flicked to the Amy flashbacks :/ I get why Dean feels guilty about that, tho - he should

And since it was obviously true She'd wanted to be a hunter even before she'd met them, and she explained it in that S2 episode. It was a bit stupid even trying to pin it on Dean, really.