The Girl Who Waited

Just started watching it

Its great

i was so sad as well. my eyes weren't tearing up but still it was so sad. Old Amy died

Rory I hate the Doctor.

Oh my God! Really?! you liked it?! I thought it was alright, but it just really.. cheesy & irritating. I liked the idea that Amy had to save herself, and that she was only person stubborn enough, but the rest of it was kinda stupid.

The garden was cool, but old Amy was just being an idiot :/ I mean, why would she want to keep all of her memories if her life was as bad as she said it was?! That's just plain retarded! Rory was alright, the Doctor was just average and Amy was downright annoying.

It does make sense thought. I mean imagine if you lived 30 years of your life, just to know that they will be ended. I wouldn't want to die, even considering how those years have been sent. Although if the doctor saved her, her life would be changed but its not technically her life, it will be younger amy's. She's already lived and she will be nothing

i thought it was better than last weeks episode but i didn't like the robots

Yeah, but if I lived 30 years of my life and they were such 'hell' then I think a do-over would be great. I mean, yeah, technically Amy & Old Amy weren't the same person, but Old Amy had to admit that the younger Amy had a way better life than she did It just seemed stupid that she would say no. I mean, if I could, there's a lot of my life I would like to re-do, and I've only just lived half of thirty years..

Amy is grumpy and stubborn though. I would of said no, i wouldn't want to die even if i know it will change my younger self. But she did choose to die in the end.

You might not have noticed, but I'm also very stubborn And people would probably say I'm grumpy, too And I wouldn't want to die, but she wasn't really died when she was dying to save herself & become someone way better, who would make the people she loves a lot happier..

I liked it Found it really emotional. Except the bit where old Amy is fighting the robots off and waiting to give the other 2 time to get to the TARDIS, and then at the last minute she only starts running, that looked cheesy. I guessed they'd only be able to save younger Amy, though.

If they saved old Amy, it would effect the show too much

I doubt she'd have been willing to just disappear and lead a boring normal life But I wish they'd hurry up and go back to searching for Melody. Or at least mention her!!!

It's unnatural and unrealistic how they're just continuing to be time and space tourists with her missing.

and Amy doesn't even seem to notice. She is just like, my baby is gone and lets go to the second best planet in the universe

That annoyed me from the first episode, and Melody was actually in that one She really just doesn't seem to care. I mean, she knows Melody will survive, but I think she should at least be a little bit sad, maybe anxious? MAYBE A FREAKING EMOTION?!

She knows she'll survive, but she also knows she'll be raised as an assassin, and will end up in prison for murder!! Shouldn't she at least want to try to alter that, even if she does know they shouldn't alter time? Shouldn't she be worrying too much to enjoy time-tourism?

Can you alter time for a time-lord? or part time-lord? Or is it something else im thinking of.

What do you mean by altering time? Why wouldn't it work?

change their past

Idk. He's said he can't change his own past, but I don't know if he could change the past of another timelord. Or maybe it's just to do with those inevitable events.

The inevitable events they're more than 110% likely end up fixing?

Since Melody is only a little bit time lord, I think changing her timeline wouldn't be too hard..

well it depends how much time-lord she is. The doctor said that she will hardly ever be able to regenerate, but she managed to twice (and quite possibly more if she hadn't even of placed all of her regenerative energy into the doctor). But then again, like the doctor said. His number 1 rule. The Doctor Lies.

Mrs P Sylar wrote:The inevitable events they're more than 110% likely end up fixing?

Since Melody is only a little bit time lord, I think changing her timeline wouldn't be too hard..

No, the actual inevitable ones Like I don't think he can go back and save Gallifrey.